Six arguments against the Resurrection refuted.

Last Updated

Apr 19, 2021

Reading Time ‘Minutes’

Word Count

These are some arguments used to explain or falsify the resurrection event.

However, the responses to these arguments add to the authenticity of the resurrection event. 

ARGUMENT 1

“Jesus' enemies would have taken His body.”

This scenario would be highly improbable because Jesus’ enemies would have certainly displayed His body if they could have, to humiliate His disciples, to control any rumors of His resurrection, as well as cut short any new religious movement that would threaten their Mosaic traditions.

ARGUMENT 2

“Jesus' followers might have taken His body.”

It is unlikely that Jesus’ followers would have taken His body because, following His crucifixion, they were profoundly disappointed and discouraged, hiding away and did not believe that He would be resurrected.

It is absurd to think that they would have invented a scheme under these conditions wherein they would steal the body to fabricate a story that they did not believe in and would later be killed for.

ARGUMENT 3

“No one had actually seen Jesus risen and people who claimed to were just hallucinating with grief.”

Hallucinations are an individual phenomena, not a group event. An individual can hallucinate; however, Jesus had appeared to more than 500 people after His resurrection as recorded in the new testament scriptures. 

Furthermore, the Bible accounts for Paul’s conversion after he witnessed the resurrected Christ, and he was not even in the state of grief (but instead was on route persecuting Christians). 

ARGUMENT 4

“The Conversion of Paul could have happened by him just exploring other faiths as it occurs in today’s world.”

The problem with this claim is that Paul did not convert based on any secondary facts (by reading sources or by someone ministering to him). But instead, he converted based on a firsthand experience when he met the risen Lord Jesus.

ARGUMENT 5

“Jesus had a twin brother who looked like him and pretended to be the Messiah after the resurrection.”

Although this is possible, the odds of this is improbable that someone would attempt such a stunt and subject himself to the torture and flogging associated with the name Jesus during that period.

ARGUMENT 6

“Jesus did not die on the cross but had merely passed out and later woke up in the tomb and escaped.”

Jesus was severely beaten, exhausted, carried a wooden cross with splinters / was exhausted / a crown of thorns was put upon His head / was nailed to the cross and then had a spear stuck in His side. 

After this, He was taken down from the cross and wrapped in 100 pounds of burial clothing and was put inside a tomb with a stone that weighed between two to three tons rolled in front of it. 

How would Jesus all of a sudden revive and un-wrap Himself and still have the strength to push the stone and escape? 

This theory is just not realistic. 

Furthermore, the guards who crucified Jesus were professional executioners, and some say that if an executioner took a man off before he was dead would face the same death.  

Even these six reasons could not contain Him in the Grave. Jesus is alive.

SEE SIMILAR QUESTIONS

What is the symbolism of the curtain being torn when Jesus was crucified?

When the gospel records the curtain being torn after Jesus crucifixion, it resembled that access for all to enter into the Holy of Holies was now open so that everyone could experience God’s presence.

Command not to tell of the miracles

Why did Jesus command not to tell others of the miracles He performed?

We see this across various scriptures where Jesus would heal someone and later command them not to tell anyone of the miracles He had performed.

Could Jesus have sinned?

Could Jesus have sinned?

Christians believe Jesus had the attributes of both Man and God during His time here on earth. He was 100% man and 100% God.

Why is Jesus called the Son of God?

In the new testament, Jesus is often referred to as the Son of God. However, on a reading of scripture, you may also notice that many other people are called Sons of God.

jesus a created being

Is Jesus a created being?

The brief answer is that Jesus is not created being, but He existed from eternity along with God the Father and God the Holy Spirit.

Jesus the passover lamb

What does it mean that Jesus is the passover lamb?

Jesus is the lamb that was offered up for our sins once and for all. He was blameless without blemish and, He finished the work on the cross so that we could be covered by God’s grace and mercy.

jesus baptism

Why did Jesus take Baptism?

John’s baptism was a call to repentance for all people; however, Jesus did not perform this act for the repentance of sins because He never sinned.

Jesus grew in wisdom?

Jesus grew in wisdom.

So how can this be possible? Was not Jesus God? If so, how could He have ‘grown’ in wisdom? Does God not already know everything?

God and man

How can Jesus be both God and Man?

We would have heard of this statement in Church that while on earth “Jesus was 100% man and 100% God.” But what does this mean?

Resurrection Risen Love

What is the Evidence for the Resurrection?

The Bible gives a reliable assurance that Jesus did exist, was crucified and people around Him saw Him resurrected after His crucifixion.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This